Compare fresh hot chocolate and make-ahead cocoa mixes from different original creators, with a practical plan for one mug, shared drinks or a dry-mix gift.
Concept imageChoose gingerbread for a spiced drink made at the stove, peppermint for a candy-flecked mix prepared with steaming whole milk, or classic powdered-milk cocoa for the flexibility of hot water or milk. Here’s what distinguishes the three credited originals.
Explore the ideas
At a glance
Compare the original recipes side by side, so you can choose before you open them.
| Recipe | Choose it for | What the preparation involves |
|---|---|---|
| Gingerbread hot chocolate Amanda Rettke · i am baker |
A spiced drink made at the stove | Spices steeped in milk and cream, molasses and melted chocolate |
| Peppermint hot cocoa mix Amanda Rettke · i am baker |
A dry mix with crushed peppermint candy | A dry blend made ahead; prepared with steaming whole milk |
| Classic hot cocoa mix Amanda Rettke · i am baker |
A plain big-batch mix | A dry blend with powdered milk; works with hot water or milk |
| 3-Ingredient Basic Hot Chocolate Ellie Krieger |
One freshly prepared plain mug | Low-fat milk, natural cocoa powder and granulated sugar; prepared for a single serving |
1. Gingerbread Hot Chocolate
Choose Amanda Rettke’s Gingerbread Hot Chocolate when making the drink is part of the evening. Ginger, cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves steep in warm milk and cream before the chocolate is melted in. Molasses gives this version its gingerbread character; it asks for more time at the stove than either dry mix below.
Whipped cream and crushed gingersnaps carry the gingerbread theme onto the mug. Serve it in evergreen stoneware against burgundy linen so the pale topping and brown crumbs stand out. Go with this version for spices and melted chocolate, rather than a jar of powder to prepare later.
Recipe by Amanda Rettke–iambaker.net · i am baker. Get the full Gingerbread Hot Chocolate recipe ↗

2. Peppermint Hot Cocoa Mix
Amanda Rettke’s Peppermint Hot Cocoa Mix combines Dutch-processed cocoa, granulated sugar, salt and finely crushed peppermint candies. The candy belongs in the dry blend, not just on top of the drink. Unlike the classic mix below, this blend has no powdered milk; the original calls for steaming whole milk.
For a peppermint-loving recipient, put the dry blend in an airtight gift jar and include the original recipe’s preparation directions, making the whole-milk requirement clear. Beside it, a cream mug with optional whipped cream and crushed peppermint shows the serving idea. Choose the classic mix instead if you want a jar that also accepts hot water.
Recipe by Amanda Rettke–iambaker.net · i am baker. Get the full Peppermint Hot Cocoa Mix recipe ↗

3. Classic Hot Cocoa Mix
Amanda Rettke’s Hot Cocoa Mix {Big Batch} is the choice for someone who wants cocoa without peppermint candy or gingerbread spices. Its dry blend combines confectioners’ sugar, Dutch-processed cocoa, powdered milk, cornstarch and salt. Keep it in an airtight container for a straightforward cocoa option alongside the more flavored choices.
Powdered milk is the useful distinction: the original accepts hot water or milk, giving this jar a different preparation option from peppermint. Optional mini marshmallows provide a simple finish. Pair a cream mug with an evergreen saucer and burgundy napkin for a Christmas serving arrangement that leaves the cocoa itself plain.
Recipe by Amanda Rettke–iambaker.net · i am baker. Get the full Hot Cocoa Mix {Big Batch} recipe ↗

Make ahead or make tonight
- Make ahead: both dry mixes are kept in an airtight container, so they can be ready before guests arrive or packed as gifts.
- Make tonight: the gingerbread version is cooked at the stove when you serve it.
- Gift jars: include the original preparation directions. The peppermint mix needs whole milk; the classic mix also works with hot water.
- Toppings: whipped cream, crushed gingersnaps, crushed peppermint or mini marshmallows let each mug match its recipe.
4. A simple single mug from Ellie Krieger
Recipe by Ellie Krieger · Ellie Krieger. Get the original 3-Ingredient Basic Hot Chocolate recipe ↗
Ellie Krieger’s three-ingredient original takes a simpler route than the flavored drinks and dry mixes above. It uses low-fat milk, natural cocoa powder and granulated sugar, and makes a single serving. There is no peppermint candy, cream or spice blend in this original. Its ingredient list gives you a useful fourth option when the occasion calls for a plain cocoa drink rather than a decorated holiday flavor.
The practical comparison is the kind of preparation you want to do. Amanda Rettke’s dry mixes let you make the blend first and prepare drinks later; Ellie’s version is made for a mug you want now. That makes the two creators useful to compare without pretending that one method is universally better. The stove-prepared gingerbread option remains the separate choice when you specifically want its spiced ingredients.
Follow Ellie’s original for the full amounts and preparation. Our illustration deliberately leaves the mug plain because extra marshmallows, whipped cream or peppermint would suggest a version that her three-ingredient recipe does not describe. The image is a serving concept, not a photograph of a drink we made or tested. For a gift, choose one of the actual dry-mix originals above rather than presenting this freshly prepared recipe as a shelf-stable jar mix.

Choose the preparation before the festive flavor
For a quiet drink tonight, compare the plain single mug with the spiced stove-prepared option. For a future gathering or a jar gift, compare the two recipes that are actually dry mixes. These are different preparation formats, not just different toppings. Decide which format fits the occasion, then follow that creator’s recipe rather than combining parts of several methods.
Before shopping, write down which original you chose, what liquid that particular recipe calls for, and how you will serve it. The classic mix accepts hot water or milk; the peppermint mix calls for milk; Ellie’s drink starts with low-fat milk. Keeping those distinctions on a short plan is more useful than assuming every cocoa recipe works the same way. No common storage time or make-ahead guarantee is implied by this selection.